Test, improve, respond: science is never ‘one-and-done’

One of the strengths of New Zealand’s fisheries management system is its ability to adapt. Twice a year, MPI’s sustainability consultations provide an opportunity to review the latest evidence and respond when circumstances change. That adaptability is only possible when decisions are grounded in robust science.

This year’s October sustainability round includes proposals for significant reductions to catch limits for eastern tarakihi. No one welcomes cuts that affect fishing businesses and coastal communities, but sustainable fisheries depend on taking action when the evidence indicates it is necessary. Fishers understand that better than anyone. Healthy fish stocks underpin their livelihoods, and sustainability is fundamental to the future of the industry.

The challenges facing eastern tarakihi are not new. Since 2018, catch limits have been reduced and fishers have implemented a range of voluntary measures to support rebuilding. Those actions have come at a real cost, but the industry remains committed to restoring the stock.

Seafood New Zealand agrees that management action is needed. The best information available indicates the stock is not where we want it to be. However, agreeing that action is required is not the same as agreeing on the scale of that action.

There is increasing evidence that broader environmental conditions may be affecting tarakihi productivity and recruitment, with similar patterns emerging in Australian waters. These changes create additional uncertainty in stock assessment models and raise important questions about some of the assumptions underpinning them.

Uncertainty is not a reason to ignore science. It is a reason to improve it.

The proposed reductions would have significant consequences for fishing businesses, crews, processors and coastal communities. Before making decisions that could put businesses at risk, we need confidence that the science is capturing the factors driving changes in the stock as accurately as possible.

That is why Seafood New Zealand supports continued investment in fisheries science and further development of the tarakihi stock assessment model, including a better understanding of environmental influences, fishing behaviour and key biological assumptions. This work will give everyone greater confidence that management decisions are proportionate, effective and based on the best available evidence.

The challenge is to strike the right balance: responding when the science tells us action is needed, while continuing to test and improve the science where important uncertainties remain. That willingness to adapt – both in management and in our understanding of the resource – is one of the reasons New Zealand’s fisheries management system is recognised among the strongest in the world.

Latest News

BERL Report website tile

Seafood industry’s $2.45 billion contribution to NZ

September 3, 2026
csm_Chathams_4b4830855b

A visit to the Chatham Islands: science, seafood and a community built on determination

August 21, 2026
csm_Chathams_4b4830855b

A visit to the Chatham Islands: science, seafood and a community built on determination

August 21, 2026

Search